Headline Reporting, SLANTED
The HEADLINE is probably the most important part for getting a story read.
Headlines are not done accidentally. look What these papers chose for headline on the SAME STORY....includes time line.
ARE ANY HEADLINES MIS-LEADING???
HERE is MY ANALYSIS.
Makes you wonder what you miss when you read only one story?
What do you think?
All reporting the same story:
15 Iraqi civilians killed as US aircraft target al-Qaida leaders Guardian Unlimited 01:44 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
Women and children die in US strike Scotsman.com 01:34 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
U.S. attack kills 9 kids MSNBC 01:33 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS, very misleading )
15 Iraqi civilians killed in US air strikes Guardian Unlimited 01:27 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
Women, children killed in air strike near Baghdad News.com.au 00:55 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
Iraq: Women, children killed in air strike near Baghdad The Mercury 00:38 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
U.S. says 15 civilians, including 9 children, killed in raid targeting al-Qaeda in Iraq San Diego Union-Tribune, California 00:30 ( NO MENTION OF NUMBER OF TERRORIST )
US air strike kills 34 in Iraq Stuff.co.nz 00:10 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
U.S. Assault on Al-Qaeda in Iraq Insurgents Kills Nine Children,... Bloomberg 00:10 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS KILLED )
9 children among 34 killed in U.S. raid in Iraq Japan Today 23:56 11-Oct-07 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
U.S. raid in Iraq kills civilians, including children CTV.ca 23:42 11-Oct-07 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
U.S. strike kills 19 insurgents and 15 civilians Reuters.co.uk 23:41 11-Oct-07 ( BALANCED )
10:57am Air strikes kill Iraqi insurgents TVNZ 23:10 11-Oct-07 ( NO MENTION OF CIVILIANS )
Air strikes kill Iraqi insurgents TVNZ 23:10 11-Oct-07 ( NO MENTION OF CIVILIANS )
Iraq: 15 civilians, including 9 children, killed in raid St Rosa's News Station (kfty.com), California 23:04 11-Oct-07 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
9 Children Killed in U.S. Raid in Iraq Missoulian, Montana 23:04 11-Oct-07 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
7:57am US air strikes kill women, child... The Australian 23:03 11-Oct-07 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
U.S. says 15 civilians, including 9 children, killed in raid targeting al-Qaida in Iraq Santa Barbara News Press, California 23:02 11-Oct-07 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS KILLED )
US air strikes kill 34 in Iraq Ninemsn 23:00 11-Oct-07 ( NO MENTION OF CIVILIANS )
US air strikes kill women, children The Daily Telegraph, Australia 23:00 11-Oct-07 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
US air strike kills 15 women, children The Daily Telegraph, Australia 22:54 11-Oct-07 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
Iraq: US air strikes kill 19 insurgents, 15 civilians YnetNews 22:48 11-Oct-07 ( BALANCED )
Strikes kill 19 insurgents, 15 civilians canada.com 22:43 11-Oct-07 ( BALANCED )
U.S. kill 13 al-Qaeda fighters National Post 22:42 11-Oct-07 ( NO MENTION OF CIVILIANS )
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
19 had misleading headlines,
no mention of terrorists, gives false impression.
3 didn't mention civilian deaths.
3 BALANCED,
Mentioned both civilian and terrorist deaths.
Guess we shouldn't just scan the headlines, misleading.
What does this say about the slant of reporting and the fight for the hearts and minds ? Even in USA?
Gerald
Headlines are not done accidentally. look What these papers chose for headline on the SAME STORY....includes time line.
ARE ANY HEADLINES MIS-LEADING???
HERE is MY ANALYSIS.
Makes you wonder what you miss when you read only one story?
What do you think?
All reporting the same story:
15 Iraqi civilians killed as US aircraft target al-Qaida leaders Guardian Unlimited 01:44 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
Women and children die in US strike Scotsman.com 01:34 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
U.S. attack kills 9 kids MSNBC 01:33 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS, very misleading )
15 Iraqi civilians killed in US air strikes Guardian Unlimited 01:27 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
Women, children killed in air strike near Baghdad News.com.au 00:55 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
Iraq: Women, children killed in air strike near Baghdad The Mercury 00:38 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
U.S. says 15 civilians, including 9 children, killed in raid targeting al-Qaeda in Iraq San Diego Union-Tribune, California 00:30 ( NO MENTION OF NUMBER OF TERRORIST )
US air strike kills 34 in Iraq Stuff.co.nz 00:10 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
U.S. Assault on Al-Qaeda in Iraq Insurgents Kills Nine Children,... Bloomberg 00:10 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS KILLED )
9 children among 34 killed in U.S. raid in Iraq Japan Today 23:56 11-Oct-07 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
U.S. raid in Iraq kills civilians, including children CTV.ca 23:42 11-Oct-07 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
U.S. strike kills 19 insurgents and 15 civilians Reuters.co.uk 23:41 11-Oct-07 ( BALANCED )
10:57am Air strikes kill Iraqi insurgents TVNZ 23:10 11-Oct-07 ( NO MENTION OF CIVILIANS )
Air strikes kill Iraqi insurgents TVNZ 23:10 11-Oct-07 ( NO MENTION OF CIVILIANS )
Iraq: 15 civilians, including 9 children, killed in raid St Rosa's News Station (kfty.com), California 23:04 11-Oct-07 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
9 Children Killed in U.S. Raid in Iraq Missoulian, Montana 23:04 11-Oct-07 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
7:57am US air strikes kill women, child... The Australian 23:03 11-Oct-07 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
U.S. says 15 civilians, including 9 children, killed in raid targeting al-Qaida in Iraq Santa Barbara News Press, California 23:02 11-Oct-07 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS KILLED )
US air strikes kill 34 in Iraq Ninemsn 23:00 11-Oct-07 ( NO MENTION OF CIVILIANS )
US air strikes kill women, children The Daily Telegraph, Australia 23:00 11-Oct-07 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
US air strike kills 15 women, children The Daily Telegraph, Australia 22:54 11-Oct-07 ( NO MENTION OF TERRORISTS )
Iraq: US air strikes kill 19 insurgents, 15 civilians YnetNews 22:48 11-Oct-07 ( BALANCED )
Strikes kill 19 insurgents, 15 civilians canada.com 22:43 11-Oct-07 ( BALANCED )
U.S. kill 13 al-Qaeda fighters National Post 22:42 11-Oct-07 ( NO MENTION OF CIVILIANS )
xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
19 had misleading headlines,
no mention of terrorists, gives false impression.
3 didn't mention civilian deaths.
3 BALANCED,
Mentioned both civilian and terrorist deaths.
Guess we shouldn't just scan the headlines, misleading.
What does this say about the slant of reporting and the fight for the hearts and minds ? Even in USA?
Gerald
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home